Kubuntu 11.10 – A Very Early Review

A very early review of Kubuntu 11.10
Is Ocelot ready to pounce? Or is it all oneiric?

In the twilight hours of this morning, I thought I’d take a look at the new Kubuntu 11.10, codenamed “Oneiric Ocelot”. Well, it seemed like a good idea at the time, in my half-awake non-caffeinated state.

Knowing how much you all dislike Ubuntu Unity and how many of you might be considering a change to Kubuntu, I thought you might like a non-technical peek review of Oneiric.

I downloaded the 32bit iso from Ubuntu, created a virtual machine in VirtualBox, loaded the iso and booted the machine.

Within a couple of seconds I was looking at a boot menu asking me to “Load Kubuntu”. And that’s where the fun began. KWin crashed not just once but every time I started the virtual machine to load Oneiric.

The current version of 11.10 is an Alpha release so I wasn’t surprised to hit an error so soon in the trial. The error was severe enough that it prevented a desktop environment from loading without me dropping to a shell; and that took a bit of cunning because it couldn’t be done with key presses from within the virtual machine. Usually one would drop to a shell by pressing Ctrl+Alt and a function key such as F1 or F2 but in this case it only affected my host system.

To get access to the shell I had to boot the machine and press F6 followed by escape to enable me to edit the line of code that gets the machine to boot the OS. I deleted the “QUIET SPLASH–” commands then pressed Enter to boot the OS followed by a tapping the Escape key every few seconds.

With my eyes fixed rigidly to the output printed to screen, as soon as I saw the shell prompt I flung my hands to the keyboard and typed “startx” then quickly pressed Return before Kubuntu had chance to start loading the desktop. This started the X Window manager and gave me a desktop with an installer icon on it which I quickly clicked to initiate the installation of Kubuntu 11.10.

The installation ran smoothly from that point onwards.

I let the installer partition the virtual drive automatically and set it to download non-free software and install updates as it worked. I restarted the computer once the installation had completed and this time it loaded a graphical desktop. But, hahaha, KWin crashed again. Thankfully it didn’t take the desktop with it.

The first thing I did on first boot was to install 12 updates that had downloaded but not installed during Oneiric’s installation.

With this running in a virtual machine, the next thing I did was install VirtualBox Guest Additions followed by a quick restart to activate the updates. This time KWin didn’t crash. I later discovered that that was only because OpenGL had been disabled to protect the system from further crashes. I re-enabled it via System Settings>Desktop Effects. But that’s not the end of the story and a little more is explained in First Impressions.

Noticing an absence of my favourite package manager, Synaptic, I installed it with sudo apt-get build-dep synaptic; sudo apt-get install synaptic. It installed faultlessly.

Oneiric uses Muon as its package manager and it isn’t currently accessible from System Settings, but it is listed in Kicker under System. Software sources are edited through Kicker>Settings>Software Sources. An alternative is to install Synaptic and use it to both install software and to add or enable repositories.

Next came the activation of several repositories via Synaptic (Settings>Repositories>Other software). Two repositories needed enabling: Canonical Partners and Independent plus their source code repos. I added the ppa:kubuntu-ppa repository along with ppa:kubuntu-ppa/experimental to ensure the very latest (probably very unstable at this point) updates. As it’s a test environment I thought what the hell, I might as well. The experimental repository contains “KDE Framework, Applications and Workspace 4.7 RC 1″ packages as stated at Kubuntu.org. If you didn’t get it from that, Kubuntu 11.10 will ship with KDE 4.7.

A repository reload showed I had around 12mb of packages to install, which I did. And a sudo apt-get dist-upgrade installed a few more.

At this point, KDE Partition Manager reports the root drive to be using 3.48 GiB (3,731,275,776 Bytes) of space. Quite large for a clean install of Kubuntu but still not as big as a clean install of Windows 7 Ultimate (I think that was around 7 or 8 GiB).

First Impressions

It is an Alpha release and it shows.

It still uses the KDE login splash screen that is used in Kubuntu’s earlier incarnations and the desktop background listed in Desktop Settings failed to load (I’m assuming it is supposed to). Both are easily rectified. The former through System Settings>Workspace Appearance and the latter by right-clicking the desktop and selecting Desktop Settings.

11.10 boots almost as fast as 11.04. Even after installing the software updates made available through the added PPA repositories, it took around 60 seconds to boot to a working OS. First boot after Oneiric’s installation dragged for about 3 minutes and the reboot after the installation of Guest Additions, well, I thought it wasn’t going to make it to a desktop: it felt as though it took between 5 and 10 minutes. Boots since then have taken a counted time of around 60 seconds to reach a working desktop.

Applications seem quicker to load in 11.10 than in 11.04. The Additional Drivers application wouldn’t load at all. 11.10 reports jockey-kde crashes whenever I try to load Additional Drivers. The error “jockey-kde crashed with ImportError in search(): No module named kurllabel” has been reported to Launchepad by me and two other users thus far.

After re-activating OpenGL and Desktop Effects, KWin reported a whole series of effects it couldn’t enable:

  • Blur
  • Box Switch
  • Cover Switch
  • Desktop Cube
  • Dashboard
  • Desktop Grid
  • Dialog Parent
  • Fade
  • Highlight Window
  • Login
  • Logout
  • Minimize Animation
  • Outline
  • Present Windows
  • Screenshot
  • Slide
  • Sliding popups
  • Startup Feedback
  • Taskbar Thumbnails
  • Translucency
  • Zoom

I had similar issues with Ubuntu 11.04 being unable to run Unity within a VirtualBox virtual machine due to an incompatible graphics adapter. It’s probable KWin couldn’t enable the above effects for the same reason though that’s just a guess.

I’m glad to report OpenGL and Desktop Effects stayed enabled this time and didn’t crash on reboots.

Changing the desktop effects compositor to XRender caused only Blur, Cover Switch, Desktop Cube, Screenshot and Startup Feedback effects to be disabled.

Oneiric comes with a Firefox installer application just like Natty does. This one installs Firefox 6. The installation works fine and I was able to play Youtube music videos without needing to install plugins such as Flash (Flash is one of the non-free software offered for install during Oneiric’s installation). Sound works great.

I haven’t noticed any spectacular applications supplied with Oneiric; they’re pretty similar to those given in 11.04. It’s more a case of what’s missing than what’s new.

Here’s an abridged list of the applications currently installed with 11.10 by default. This list is derived from the contents of /usr/share/applications. Leave a comment if you want to know whether a particular application is present or missing from the default installation of 11.10 and I will gladly take a peek.

  • Akregator
  • Amarok
  • Ark
  • BlueDevil
  • Dolphin
  • DragonPlayer
  • Firefox Installer
  • Gwenview
  • K3b
  • KAddressBook
  • Kate
  • KCalc
  • KDE Groupware Wizard
  • KFontView
  • KInfo Center
  • Klipper
  • KMag
  • KMail2
  • KMix
  • KNotes
  • Konsole
  • Kontact
  • Kopete
  • Korganizer
  • KPatience
  • Kppp
  • Krdc
  • Krftb
  • KRandRTray
  • KSnapShot
  • KTimeTracker
  • KTorrent
  • Kvkbd
  • KWalletManager
  • LibreOffice (Calc, Draw, Impress, Math and Writer)
  • Muon
  • Nepomuk
  • Okular
  • Partition Manager
  • Quassel
  • Rekonq
  • Software Sources
  • Synaptiks
  • System Settings
  • Uxterm
  • Xterm

Kicker behaves a little differently to the way it does in 11.04. I expect this is due to a KDE change more than a change in Kubuntu. In 11.04, when you navigate to an application group, such as Graphics, there is a back button at the left-hand-side of the menu. That’s gone in 11.10. In 11.10, Kicker shows navigation breadcrumbs at the top of the menu so, for example, when viewing Graphics, the top of the menu displays “All Applications>Graphics”. I prefer the way it’s done in 11.04. Though I see the merit of using breadcrumbs, I fail to understand why the back button has been removed considering it’s a nifty way to navigate Kicker. Check the picture below to see the new Kicker layout.

Screenshot: The New Kicker on Kubuntu 11.10 Alpha
Kick of the Ocelot. It’s poised for action!

All in all, I think Oneiric Ocelot is a nice product. It seems pretty much the same as Kubuntu 11.04 and I will replace my current desktop environment with a clean install of 11.10 when its final release is ready.

Most of the Ubuntu Repositories listed here are ready for Oneiric. Those that do not currently work only fail because the Oneiric repo is yet to be created by the repo’s maintainer.

If you need to access 11.10′s boot menu, perhaps to use the recovery console, then you only need to hit the Shift key as soon as the system begins to boot.

One last point before I throw it over to you: OpenGL caused KWin crashed just before I published this post! It didn’t take my desktop with it.

So, I’m looking forward to reading your experiences and expectations from 11.10. You know where to comment :-)

Comments

    • says

      Because it’s easier than taking a computer apart to install an empty hdd to install a new OS onto it for testing. I do take your point, though, and as soon as the final release is published I will review it with a non virtual machine installation.

      If it makes you feel any better, the host machine has an unlocked AMD Phenom II B50 Black Edition CPU (unlocked to 4 cores) installed on an ASUS M4A78LT-M-LE motherboard, with 2x2GiB DIMM Synchronous 1333 MHz (0.8 ns) and an off-board ATI Radeon HD 3600 VGA (the on-board VGA is enabled too). The VM uses an ICH9 Chipset, 1 CPU, 1 GiB of RAM, 50 GiB hard drive (on it’s own partition) and takes advantage of the host CPU’s virtualization support. Not a bad system to run it on.

      I’ve just installed a few hundred MB of updates that were released tonight. Hopefully KWin will behave a little better. I’ve changed to XRender from OpenGL for now though.

      Thanks for posting :-)

  1. jrdls says

    you should disable the blur effect and possibly desktop cube too. They  both crash kwin in my netbook.

    • says

      Thanks for the idea, I tried it but it didn’t work. I will disable all desktop effects then re-enable them one-by-one and see whether I can find the culprit/s. Will have to wait until a little later though.

  2. istok says

    “in my half-awake non-caffeinated state”there’s a host of better things a person can do in that state. sad to waste in on ubuntu and its feeble minded offspring.just my 2 cents.

    • says

      There are plenty of things I could have done instead but doing as I did gave you something to talk about so it wasn’t a waste :p

    • says

      Kubuntu beats Windoze Hands Down.  Any time you spend with Kubuntu is not a waste, but a pleasure.  I don’t waste time anymore because I no longer use Windoze.  No more time wasted with viruses, spyware, or expensive software.  Anyone who makes an attempt to get to know Kubuntu will aim to leave Windoze.

  3. Anonymous says

    Looks awesome and the more I get angry at Unity the more I think I will just switch to Kubuntu when 11.10 comes out (if I don’t switch sooner, maybe when KDE 4.7 packages came out, they are really teasing me with the reviews of KDE)

    • says

      I like the layout of KDE and I like the way desktop folders  can be browsed without clicking them (they can be set to popup when hovered over). If you want to try KDE, you can install it alongside Gnome/Unity without it affecting your default desktop. Install Tasksel (sudo apt-get install tasksel) then run it by typing “sudo tasksel” into the commandline and you will be able to select the Kubuntu desktop metapackage (works better than installing it “sudo apt-get install kubuntu-desktop” because Tasksel pulls in everything else that’s needed to get it to work smoothly).

  4. says

    Unity is OK….-ish…I think it needs a little bit refining. For example the global menu is a decent idea but I don’t like how it auto hides the File,Edit,etc. menus. The Unity launcher is also a good idea but it needs to have more options and be a little more user friendly. Overall I’d give unity 4/10 stars. Good ideas….bad application…..Hey! Like Windows ME or Vista!

    • says

      I agree with you. Unity will mature over time but it’s developers need to listen more to Ubuntu’s users and speedup making it more customizable. I couldn’t publicly tell you some of the search terms that have brought people to my article on Ubuntu 11.04.

  5. Bsdsolarux says

     ya really, the 1st poster was right,  and no, i don’t wanna know “why” you review in a virtual env ???, and alpha at that.

    • says

      Well I’m gonna tell you anyway :p

      I reviewed Alpha because that’s what was available several months ago when I wrote a “very early review”. Someone would need to be a massive idiot not to understand that an early review of an Alpha product will likely point out some of the flaws of the Alpha product. Nearly everybody knows that an Alpha is not a Beta and neither of the former two are final products i.e expect errors.

      Have you tried to upgrade from 11.04 to 11.10 Final? Give it a go. You’re going to love my next post ;)

  6. Bsdsolarux says

    But, Kubuntu 11.10 (RELEASE) is now here, can you please review all this again ?.
    much appreciated.
    Thankyou.

    • says

      I upgraded my main OS on the day of release. The upgrade wasn’t smooth but since ironing out many of the kinks the OS seems to be running fine. I will do a fresh install on a non virtual machine but I’m giving it a week before doing so; this way most teething bugs will be resolved and the review will be fairer.

  7. Esaterror80 says

    kubuntu 11.10 animation dosn’t smooth at all like 11.04..my recurrent hardware quite high end but still cant make me is satisfied

    • says

      Do you mean the desktop effects? Change the renderer from OpenGL to XRender (System Settings > Desktop Effects > Advanced tab). If you have Compiz installed, remove it because it can interfere with KDE.

Leave a Reply